Tuesday, March 01, 2005

3] Post-colonial education: Possible direction

WHICH WAY TO POSTCOLONIAL EDUCATIONAL PARADIGM? CRITICAL THEORY REASSERTED

by Azly Rahman

Columbia University, New York

In our effort to make sense of the multiplicity of perspectives leading to the formulation of an educational paradigm based upon “postcolonial sensibilities”, we are faced with the dilemma of choice among many which would be critical enough for liberatory work in educational reform. This brief literature review attempts to answer the question ‘Which perspective is useful in our conceptualizing of a paradigm, drawing illuminations from critical theory as one liberating pedagogy?’ The work of McLaren and Giarelli (1995) on critical theory, Smith (1994) on the study of colonists and McClintock (1992) on destroying binary opposition in defining postcolonialism will be reflected upon. The relevancy of the research question grew out of my believe that although the subaltern perspectives emerging in postcolonial studies can offer illuminating multidimensionalities in approaching in educational critique and reform, a goal-oriented path is needed; one which particularly concerns education for critical consciousness.

REVIEW OF SELECTED LITERATURE

McLaren and Giarelli (1995) writing from the perspective of critical pedagogy in the genre of neo-Leftism appeal to social and educational researchers to commit themselves to the growing solidarity in scholarship that promises a hope for the triumph of education for liberation. Whilst acknowledging the value of interpretivist research, McLaren and Giarelli (1995) contended that it is still situated in the “domain of cultural diversity” and as such, non-liberatory in nature. (p.16) What is needed is then for its situatedness in “cultural difference” encapsulated within a body of methodological knowledge which cognitively link political and ethical dimensions of theorizing to liberation. Postmodernism or postcolonial studies, they assert, can become powerful hybridizing endeavors when its development is politically engaging and cautious to the potentially “disarming powers” of both neo-liberalism and neo-conservatism. Whilst McLaren and Giarelli (1995) offer such a pedagogical and methodological suggestion on postcolonial paradigm, Andrea L. Smith (1994) suggests anthropologists to reconceptualize the question of postcolonial studies so that not only the colonized should be looked at but also the colonists who themselves suffered from the institutional, ideological, and psycho-pathological conditions they created at the junctures of colonialism’s history.

Smith (1994) believed that by “looking at ourselves” via engaging in the “anthropology of colonists” researchers not only can gain from a potentially painful but therapeutic value in the will to knowledge, but also can be introduced avenues to the study of power, domination, and structural violence – all these in turn will honestly situate the study of colonist formation in its most legitimate sense. Through our looking at the complexity of the colonial situation, juxtapositioning with the already burgeoning research on the colonized, Smith (1994) believed that a holistic picture of truth and method could effectively be made to emerge. Whilst Smith (1994) focused our attention to studying the socio-psychological makeup of the power brokers, Ann McClintock (1992) argued that one can be semantically drawn into the ideologically shackling conception of history as binary constructs; of the “triumph” of Capitalism over Communism and of the march of colonialism into another epoch called “postcolonialism”. Drawing primarily from conflict paradigm in international politics, using Marxist linguistic analysis to deconstruct the term “postcolonialism” and drawing engaging case studies in conflict amongst nations, McClintock (1992) concluded that contemporary issues of progress must be looked at as a “post-colonial” march of United States’ hegemonic interests aided by its supporting instruments of domination such as the IMF and World Bank. McClintock (1992) called for one to delve into innovative theorizing to counter singularizing tendencies in looking at “post-colonialism”. In comparing and contrasting McLaren and Giarelli (1995), Smith (1994), and McClintock (1992) as analyses and assertions related to the pathway to a post-colonial educational paradigm, a typology of analysis strengthened by critical theory can be discerned.

Whilst McLaren and Giarelli (1995) suggests a methodological orientation based primarily upon the Freirian approach to doing educational and social research, Smith (1994) offers a conceptual perspective in looking at the aftermath of colonialism on the colonizer and the colonized, and McClintock reminds us of the issue of political economic injustices in the global system. These authors approach their analysis predominantly from a critical theory perspective looking at power structure and the means and methods to dismantle it. McLaren and Giarelli ‘s (1995) call for political and ethical solidarity for a program of educational praxis, Smith’s (1994) call for a critical study of colonists in anthropology, and McClintock’s (1992) semantic analytical approach to the politics of the term “ postcolonialism” can be encapsulated as a reassertion of Marxist humanist analysis pointing towards a systematic paradigm of analysis needed to be arrived at if one is to construct as educational paradigm for psychological liberation in this “post-colonial” era. A focused critical view as this can offer the guiding light to embattle the rugged terrain of “postmodernism”; a terrain which may offer multiple perspective which can be potentially blinding and excessively relativizing. Thus, in those three analyses, the critical theoretical ties that bind can perhaps give one the necessary grip on the slippery ground of postmodern foundationalism. But if the critical theoretical dimensions provide the strength, weaknesses can also be discerned from the perspectives.

In McLaren and Giarelli (1995) for example, perplexing is the goal to be achieved in a multicultural, liberatory, and critical pedagogy. To gather subaltern voices, rally them politically and ethically as a counter-sphere of public opinion would mean to rally against and ideological Other. Would the McLaren and Giarelli ‘s (1995) counter ideological Other be yet another construct perhaps shackled by another ideology itself in the classic Marxist conception of anti-thesis versus thesis? Where and what is the locus of control critical pedagogy is attempting to decenter and deconstruct? Is power, in this sense homegenic, or heterogenic? What can be the scenario of a society free from ideology and oppression McLaren and Giarelli (1995) envision, of which these authors failed to have us imagine? Whilst Smith (1994) is illuminating in her suggestion for an anthropology of colonists, can this domain then develop into a body of knowledge which would have the potential of being further developed into a perspective apologetic to the agents of colonialism which then in turn betray the call for honesty Smith (1994) set forth in the first place? Therein I believe lie the danger, given the polemic nature of the development of knowledge production in fields, which are subjective in nature. Whilst McClintock’s (1992) semantic analysis is helpful in keeping us on track in conceptualizing other legitimate issues such as balance of power, militarism, and hegemonic interests of the powerful industrialized economies borne out of the military-industrial complex superstructure, hers is short of the critical analysis of power relations in nation-states based philosophical-ideological foundations such as Islam, Confucianism, Hinduism, and the like; those emerging out of the “ill-conceived” notion of the end of history. In short, McClintock (1992) bases her analysis, historical-materialistic determinism and World systems in character, to look at hegemonic interests in international relations without critically examining the complexity of distributive injustices and repression in the so-called Third World nation-states.

Having briefly discussed perspectives which bind and divide and the critical dimensions unanswered in each one of them and consequently situate these within my search for a desirable path to postcolonial education paradigm, some usefulness of the perspectives can be discerned. From McClintock’s (1992) perspective, it is useful to not only look at hegemonic interest in international power relations as evident in the manner linguistic connotations are applied to the term “postcolonialism” but also to go deeper into analyzing such relations at the societal level be they in societies comprising of Marxists, feminists, or ethnocentric xenophobics. From Smith’s (1994) perspective it is useful to not only look at the eventuality of an anthropology of colonists but also its counter-revolutionary ideological formation apologetic to the cause of the colonists. From McLaren and Giarelli (1995), the critical pedagogy can be all the more useful if and only if the agents to be liberated must be made to conceive what it means to be “fully liberated” and for them to be provided the answer to the question “to be free from what?” The way to a desirable postcolonial educational paradigm can be riddled, along the way, with more problematic and multidirectional signposts if the original intention to unite the multivocal Others turn into yet another agenda to divide them into multi-ideological followers!

REFERENCES

Smith, A.L. (1994). Colonialism and the poisoning of Europe: Towards an antropology of colonists. Journal of Anthropological Research, 50, (pp. 383-393).

McClintock, A. (1992). The angel of progress: Pitfalls of the term “postcolonialism.” Social Text, Spring , (pp. 1-15).

McLaren, P.L., & Giarelli, J.M. (Eds.) (1995). Critical Theory and educational research. Albany: SUNY Press.

42 comments:

Anonymous said...

Whіle onlinе Fгee Datіng ωill ԁеtermine ωho you
are саreer minԁed, then I stгοngly recommend you tаke aсtіon tοday!
Whilе Pегry and John ԁеcіԁeԁ to
write abοut my аge, sοme infοгmatіоn need tο
go out the κinks, аnd the purse should be hapру іn her
own ωay to plаnning a mаrriage.
On line fгee dating hаs largely bеcome a ѕoсіopath thаt will woгk against you, put that kind
of rеlаtіonshіρs. Ѕο I рut ԁetails
in otheг countrіeѕ, North Carolina
Ѕtаte, Αuburn, USC football, sayѕ οnlinе fгee dаting serѵicеs.



My blog :: http://2datingtoday.net
Also see my website: http://1datingintheusa.com/

Anonymous said...

Its like you read my thoughts! You seem to know so much about this, like
you wrote the guide in it or something. I think that you could do
with some p.c. to drive the message home a little bit, but other than that, that
is fantastic blog. A fantastic read. I will definitely be back.



Also visit my blog: diesel jeans outlet Online
my web page :: Ted

Anonymous said...

In thе early 20th Сentury, nеon sunglаssеs
can be fоund on a paіr with a minimаliѕt
all white outfit thаt you do, аnd 70s. In Flοrida, you
havе аn adverse іmρaсt οn faѕt deliveгy anԁ 14 day returns wіth frее shipρing foг orders over $25 get fгeе shіpping.
In fact, most of them. You can do to prοtect theiг
еyes.

Review mу ωeb ѕite; Neon sunglasses aviator sunglasses police sunglasses
my web page > aviator sunglasses

Anonymous said...

If you wish for to improνe your knowleԁge simply keeρ visitіng this
web site аnԁ be updateԁ with the mοst recent informаtion pοsted here.


Also visit my page: small loans

Anonymous said...

vіe in sciencе games for to Аct as gameѕ sρecifically designed for thаt function.
Тo Delight Online spoгtѕ аctivities, you ρauperiѕm exactly the up arrοw makes yоu Leap out tο Garner аpρles and pοints.


My sitе: game

Anonymous said...



Also visit my homepage ... web page

Anonymous said...

Many onlіne tattoo gallerieѕ keеp сompetitions for the best tattoο ideas.
Laԁiеs ѕhould thinκ about theѕe, basеԁ οn their рlасеmеnt.
Αѕ а website owner, you need to fіnd wаys foг
wеb νiѕitοrѕ to finԁ your sіte, mеaning
you hаve tο generаte lots of tгaffic and make
an effοгt to гank high in
search engines.

Αlso ѵisit my web-site ... bear tattoos

Anonymous said...

Dау 1 Thе haгdеѕt only tea аnd minerаl wateг- Bгeakfaѕt:
Α cup of teа giѵеs an еmmediate energy lift withοut the sidе effects of the green Рure Grеen Coffее
Beаn Extract 800 Mg product гemains. Shoulԁ Ӏ gо to is a vеry tough battle thаt obeѕe indіviԁuals have tο creаtе.
This is only a booѕteг or enhancеr.


Also visit mу blog; pure green coffee extract

Anonymous said...

But, thеse ԁays therе aгe manу effеctive рure gгеen coffee bean еxtгаct гeviеwѕ available
to trу tο ρut together a ѕtorу, аnԁ share it еаsily.
Υou сan sіmply rеlу on dietѕ аnd ехеrcises that mаy take months
or еven yеars befоre уou can
mаκe an eaѕy choice by selеcting
gгеen рuге gгeen coffee bеan еxtrаct revieωs pills, yοu may gгadually increase
dosаge. ρurе gгeen coffee bеаn еxtract геvіews havе commonlу сomе from natural souгcеs liκе heгbѕ
but most of thеm can be quitе an аlternate prοceԁuгe.


Also viѕіt my web-sіte; pure green coffee extract

Anonymous said...

I all the time used to ѕtuԁy pаragrаρh іn news pаpеrs but
noω as I am a user οf ωeb therefoгe from now Ι am using nеt fог contеnt, thаnκѕ to web.


Alsο viѕit my ωеb ρage - medicinasalternativas.blogspot.fr

Anonymous said...

This design is steller! You most certainly know how to keep a reader amused.
Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved
to start my own blog (well, almost...HaHa!) Great job.
I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it.

Too cool!

my web page; Newport Beach catering

Anonymous said...

Good way of telling, and pleasant post to get information about my presentation subject, which
i am going to present in university.

My web site - computer service charlotte north carolina

Anonymous said...

This post presents clear idea for the new people of blogging, that
really how to do running a blog.

Look into my site: Reverse Hotmail

Anonymous said...

Hiya! I simply want to give an enormous thumbs up for the good
information you’ve got right here on this post. I can be coming again to
your blog for more soon.

Also visit my web blog :: semo athletics staff directory

Anonymous said...

I think everything posted was very reasonable. But, what
about this? what if you added a little information?
I mean, I don't wish to tell you how to run your blog, but what if you added something to maybe grab people's attention?
I mean "3] Post-colonial education: Possible direction" is a little plain.
You might peek at Yahoo's home page and watch how they create post titles to grab people to open the links. You might try adding a video or a related picture or two to grab readers interested about what you've got to say.
Just my opinion, it might bring your posts a little livelier.


my website - http://wiki.diagcomputing.org/

Anonymous said...

Have you ever thought about creating an e-book or guest
authoring on other sites? I have a blog based upon on the same subjects you discuss and would love to have you
share some stories/information. I know my readers would value your work.
If you're even remotely interested, feel free to send me an e-mail.

Feel free to surf to my homepage books on premature ejaculation

Anonymous said...

Heya are using Wordpress for your blog platform?

I'm new to the blog world but I'm trying to get started
and set up my own. Do you need any html coding knowledge to make your
own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!

My web-site :: easy methods to control fast ejaculation

Anonymous said...

Hey! Do you use Twitter? I'd like to follow you if that would be ok. I'm absolutely enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.


my webpage - http://www.802.11abgn.com/

Anonymous said...

Very soon this website will be famous amid all blogging visitors, due to it's good articles or reviews

Here is my website :: how to last longer in bed without taking pills

Anonymous said...

Everyone loves it when folks get together and share views.
Great site, keep it up!

Here is my blog :: premature ejaculation medicine allopathic

Anonymous said...

Hello there, I discovered your blog by way of Google whilst searching for a related subject, your web site got here up, it appears good.
I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
Hi there, just was aware of your weblog via Google, and found that
it is truly informative. I'm gonna watch out for brussels. I will be grateful in case you continue this in future. Many other people can be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!

my blog - how to hold off ones ejaculation

Anonymous said...

I must thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this blog.

I'm hoping to check out the same high-grade blog posts from you later on as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has motivated me to get my very own site now ;)

my web site: causes of premature ejaculation and the treatment

Anonymous said...

Whats up! I just would like to give an enormous thumbs up
for the nice info you might have here on this post.

I will be coming again to your weblog for extra soon.


My blog SEO收費

Anonymous said...

Heya i am for the first time here. I came across this board and I find It truly useful &
it helped me out much. I am hoping to offer one thing again and help others like you aided me.



my weblog Premature Ejaculation Tips Video

Anonymous said...

Hello! I simply wish to give a huge thumbs up for the good data you have got
right here on this post. I will be coming back to your
blog for more soon.

Also visit my weblog ... seoul subway new years

Anonymous said...

What's up, all is going nicely here and ofcourse every one is sharing data, that's genuinely excellent, keep up writing.


Also visit my web-site ... Home Page

Anonymous said...

Maybe your how to get girlfriend Or Wife sufficient space and are ready
to pay the whole price before having the success, you always wanted.
My second live in boyfriend didn't understand the concept of 'cocky
and funny' comes in. If you try to get the pleasure. So, what is it that a man must possess in order to attract her back? Find a woman, you will achieve it.

Here is my website ... how to get a girlfriend

Anonymous said...

Good day! I just wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the
good info you may have here on this post. I might be coming back to your weblog for extra soon.



Here is my weblog - semaphore alphabet flags

Anonymous said...

Hey! I simply would like to give a huge thumbs up for the nice info
you might have right here on this post. I will be coming again to your
weblog for more soon.

my web blog seminole county public schools skyward

Anonymous said...

In order to find the best deals on goods and services, many would consider their shopping
behavior to be of any real help to you. Before you decide to
travel as you can afford - the higher your deductible, the cheaper your auto insurance katy tx will be.


Here is my page ... continue reading this..

Anonymous said...

You don t have to say, I hate when that
happens. Real men do not forgive easily when their Tips To Attract Womens cheat on them.

Then, examine within yourselves what went wrong.
Once they explore these differences, they'll know which buttons to press.

My blog post - ways to attract women

Anonymous said...

Having auto insurance grand rapids mi will give
you a quote as quick as 5 minutes. Find out if you need to have to be a minor injury or insignificant dispute.

Their agents will be happy to assist you to access the quotes online and it alone involves
browsing the net and award the best adduce because altered companies action altered exceptional rates.
It should have a better understanding of auto insurance
grand rapids mi, so you might want to think about how you drive to set your rates.

Anonymous said...

For instant and quick approval, you can complete
you process online. If you continue to spend then you
will most-definitely want go ahead and let your fingers do the clicking on over to a debt consolidation representative to see what your
options are. Whereas the cash advance trap, surprisingly,
simple consolidate loans are often available with
much lower interest rate. Because of the security offered the lenders are
not only more likely to lend in the first place.

Also visit my page consolidate my debt

Anonymous said...

It's funny that being totally direct about what your interest in the one area I knew he would be most interested in. You realize that the past also includes those times when your ex ways to attract women is feeling that way as well. You have lost the closeness I used to scoff at the idea that they can get women have, and get me the next one in the park.

Also visit my web page ... how to attract women tips

Anonymous said...

Right here is the right website for anyone who hopes to understand this
topic. You understand a whole lot its almost hard to argue
with you (not that I personally would want to…HaHa).

You definitely put a new spin on a topic that has been discussed for many years.
Wonderful stuff, just excellent!

Here is my page; luxe vakantiehuizen

Anonymous said...

Since all insurance policies will treat the collision between your vehicle and it pays
absolutely nothing for your medical bills or property damage car insurance rates by state that has
resulted due to an accident. There you can get them on road.


Here is my site :: auto insurance

Anonymous said...

Simply, don't hold it against her if she has a boyfriend or how get a girlfriend to spend the rest of your life, sometimes you may loose your how get a girlfriend who was very close to you. Girls are attracted to women by sight, are attracted to her. Most men are not very good at for someone you really like her, this attitude will come naturally.

Look into my web site web page

Anonymous said...

You don't want to have a how get a girlfriend of yours or even a bracelet. Another stage of how to get your ex how get a girlfriend back. Although they are a shortcut to really horrifying crimes. Respect her in every way and shower her with presents but this does not need to worry about the possibility that you have seen this as well. They will not react negatively unless you are dancing - you'll just look
like a hero.

Take a look at my web page: how do you get a girlfriend (http://howtogetagirlefriend.com)

Anonymous said...

Insurance can help you greatly with all your financial needs in
the time of obtaining insurance may reduce the coverage cost.
When searching for Car Insurance Aaa Edmonton, you can
make your life better. All insurance policies are not
all created equally. You can also select to split your existing insurance policy if you consider these suggestions.


My weblog auto insurance

Anonymous said...

Nice post. I used to be checking continuously this blog and I'm impressed! Very helpful information specifically the remaining part :) I deal with such info a lot. I was looking for this certain information for a very lengthy time. Thank you and good luck.

Also visit my homepage :: xerox 8560mfp driver

Anonymous said...

After singing, you can act totally yourself and enjoy every minute of it, improving your appearance to how to attract
women. So, if you send her the wrong kind of women you love.
Their next album- MONEY BUSINESS was another world-acclaimed
hit. Well, if you walk away. You can't file away your emotions when you have this discussion with her. She's
Honest with Me Most of the time and attention you took picking the flowers for her.


Feel free to visit my blog: how to attract women tips

Anonymous said...

ecig, vapor cigarette, electronic cigarettes, smokeless cigarettes, smokeless cigarettes, e cig

About Me

My photo
Born in Singapore and grew up in Johor Baru; holds a Columbia University (New York City) doctorate in International Education Development and Masters in four areas: Education, International Affairs, Peace Studies and Communication; pursuing fifth, MFA in Creative Writing; has taught more than 50 courses in six different departments; written more than 350 analyses on Malaysia; teaching experience in Malaysia and the United States spanning over a wide range of subjects, from elementary to graduate education; has edited and authored seven books; Multiethnic Malaysia: Past, Present, Future (2009), Thesis on Cyberjaya: Hegemony and Utopianism in a Southeast Asian State (2012), The Allah Controversy and Other Essays on Malaysian Hypermodernity (2013), Dark Spring: Ideological Roots of Malaysia's GE-13 (2013), a first Malay publication Kalimah Allah Milik Siapa?: Renungan dan Nukilan Tentang Malaysia di Era Pancaroba (2014), Controlled Chaos: Essays on Mahathirism, Multimedia Super Corridor and Malaysia's 'New Politics' (2014), One Malaysia under God, Bipolar (2015); resides in the United States teaching courses in Philosophy, Cultural Studies, Political Science, and American Studies.